Our independence
How Roiva keeps the AI in Practice Index independent of its customers, partners and sales: what never changes a score, and what we disclose.
Roiva makes software that helps companies measure the return on their AI initiatives, and some companies in this index may become our customers. So it's fair to ask: do Roiva customers score higher? They don't. This policy covers every edition of the index and says how we make sure of it.
Where do scores come from?
Every score comes from the published method and nothing else.
- A script calculates every score from the public evidence. Nobody sets, adjusts or rounds a score by hand.
- The script has no way to know who our customers are. That information sits in our sales system, which the index never reads, and the research never mentions it.
- The method is fixed for each edition. A test fails if a score moves without a recorded reason, and every correction to a published result goes on the edition's public change log.
- Evidence dated after an edition's as-of date never counts toward that edition.
What never changes a score?
None of these changes a score, a leader decision or a profile:
- being, or becoming, a Roiva customer, partner, supplier or investor, or talking to our sales team;
- claiming a profile, asking for a score, or replying to our emails;
- paying Roiva for anything;
- what a partner, sponsor or adviser wants;
- information a company sends us privately.
The only thing that changes a score is a public source, dated on or before the edition's as-of date, that we missed or misread. Anyone can send us one, customer or not. The source moves the score, not the company that sent it.
What happens to information a company gives us?
Anything a company adds to its profile is labeled "company-provided", shown apart from the sourced evidence, and never counts toward a score, a leader decision or a profile, in any edition. Our terms for company-provided sections say what a company may add. Evidence a company sends us privately is treated the same way; our evidence guidelines explain what happens to it.
Who is named?
- Only AI in Practice Leaders are named in public, alphabetically, with no scores or ranks. Every other company can learn its own score privately, or claim a profile.
- Before a company is named, a person checks every source behind its score against the source itself. The check can correct a row; it can't hold back a leader whose rows are right.
- Every company in an edition is researched the same way. When a correction turns up a kind of source we missed, that kind of source is checked again for every company in the edition, not just the one that raised it.
How do we disclose our relationships?
Each edition says how many of its companies are Roiva customers, partners, suppliers or investors. We give numbers for the edition as a whole, never names, and never a count for the leaders alone. The numbers come from our sales system, are drawn up after the scores are fixed, and are dated.
| Kind | What counts |
|---|---|
| Customer | a current paying customer, or one in the 12 months before publication |
| Partner | a referral, integration, reseller or co-marketing agreement |
| Supplier | Roiva buys from the company, including insurance Roiva holds |
| Investor | the company, its venture arm, or one of its directors or executives holds Roiva equity or has committed to invest |
Does anyone pay?
No. There is no paid placement: nobody can buy a place, a badge, a profile or a review. It's free to see your score and to claim, correct or remove your profile. A leader can also ask to come off the leader list; we say how many did, and nobody moves up in its place. The badge is free to use under our published terms.
How are corrections handled?
Write to data@roiva.ai with a link to a public source. We reply within one week, and reach an outcome within 30 days, or tell you why it's taking longer and give a new date. If a correction changes the leader list or a profile, we update the edition within a week of the outcome, or tell you why not and give a new date, and record it, dated and with the reason, on the edition's change log. Disputes about the method itself (a weight, a limit, a rule) aren't corrections: we answer them when we set the next method.
How does the method change?
- The method changes only between editions, never for one already published. Each change is dated on the method page, with what changed, why, and how it moves the leader list.
- When a new edition uses a changed method, the previous edition is re-scored under it and shown alongside, so a company's movement reflects its own disclosures, not the method.
- Past results aren't rewritten. Badges are dated. A method change never withdraws one; only a recorded correction can, and the company is told first.
Who does the work?
AI research agents (Claude, made by Anthropic), working under the direction of Roiva staff, find and quote the evidence. They are given the research brief and the list of companies, never anyone's commercial status. Roiva staff set the method, and a person checks every source behind each named company.
What about conflicts of interest?
- Roiva staff declare their holdings in, and other ties to, the companies in an edition before its research begins.
- Roiva, its staff and their households, and anyone else who sees results before they are published, don't buy or sell shares, options or other positions in companies in an edition from its first draft until two full trading days after it is published. The same applies to a correction that would change the leader list, until two full trading days after it is posted.
- Each edition says whether Roiva, its staff or their households hold any position in its companies.
- A broad, diversified fund, such as a mutual fund, ETF or index fund whose holdings the holder doesn't choose, isn't a position in the companies it holds. A fund concentrated in an edition's sector or companies, such as a transportation, bank or insurance fund, is.
- Nobody's pay depends on the results.
- Our sales team may point to a published edition. It may not share an unpublished score, rank or leader status, or suggest that buying, claiming or replying changes a result.
- Our own marketing may point to a published edition and its leaders. It never presents a company as endorsing Roiva, and if it names a company that has a relationship with Roiva, it says so.
- No partner or sponsor affects any score.
Figures are claims
Every figure in the index is a claim as published, by the company or, for some figures, by its vendor or the press. None is a benchmark, and we never compare figures between companies.
This policy
This policy is versioned and dated like the method. A change is announced on the method page and applies from the next edition.
If we find we haven't followed this policy, we say so on the change log of the edition it affected, with what happened and what we did about it, and correct any result it changed.